Posted by
Dr. Brian Melton on Wednesday, May 11, 2005 2:08:00 PM
As a man thinketh in
his heart, so is he.
Proverbs 23:7 KJV
For many years now, commentators and historians observing
the culture wars have stuck to the terms “conservative” and “liberal”
consistently. The groups themselves have
taken these labels to heart, and millions wear them proudly. They are badges of honor that counts them
among in an elite army of political and social warriors who see themselves as
either defending the treasured legacy of the past or riding the cutting edge of
the transformation into a new, progressive world. Unfortunately, this passion
has obscured a simple, troublesome fact about both: the terms are now meaningless. Why?
They have effectively switched sides.
The failure of “conservatism” to grasp this fact has hamstrung its
efforts at cultural reform and could prove deadly to its resolve in the future.
In the simplest and purest form, divorced from modern
political implications, a “conservative” wants to prevent change from
occurring, while a “liberal” is someone who wants to promote change. This leads us to a simple question: “Which of the goals of the ‘conservative’
movement actually involve ‘conservation’?”
Abortion
has been legal and enthusiastically practiced for nearly an entire
generation. It long ago ceased to
be anything unusual, and is now the norm in every state in the Union.
- It has
been forty years since Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society officially turned America
into a functioning welfare state.
- Liberals
have dominated to world of academia since the 1950s. In fact, they have taken such firm
control that finding more than one real
conservative in a department of History is the exception. Trying to find one in places like
English departments is nearly akin to looking for a live Brontosaurus in Central Park.
- Though
Intelligent Design/Creationism is beginning to make a come back,
macro-evolution and secular humanism continues to be taught exclusively in
school systems around the country.
Homosexual friendly sex-ed is no longer the exception.
- It has
been roughly 100 years since the Constitution, as written, had anything to
do with this country. The norm now
is judicial activism and the limitless power of the federal government.
- In
many ways, both parties stand on very similar platforms, and have very
similar goals, as they reach out for that mythical “middle ground.” On issues like welfare and abortion,
moderate Republicans are best described as “Democrats Light.”
- Religion,
often times, is not only separate from the state, its pursuit is prevented
and even persecuted by the state.
Of course, I could go on.
My point is this:
Literal decades have passed since the “liberal” agenda became the
practical status quo for most of the country.
When that happened, the “liberals” became the “conservatives” and the
“conservatives” became the ones fighting for change. Traditionalists have become the radicals,
challenging the intact system of belief and government.
This has enormous implications for how modern advocates of
traditional values see themselves in relation to their opponents. A “conservative” is someone who generally
thinks in a defensive mindset. After
all, his or her goal is specifically to defend ground against advancing
enemies, and all decisions on tactics and strategy are made with an eye to the preservation
of an existing position or state of affairs.
In the social and cultural realm, this easily translates into
a laid back, “let-them-come-to-us” mentality that promotes inaction. It is completely
ineffective when there is little, if any, worthwhile ground left to hold. The
result is not unlike trying to win a football game by playing only red zone defense.
So, it is high time that “conservatives” realize that they
are in fact the real “liberals” in this country (if they can say it without
choking). They are trying to retake lost
ground and promote meaningful change in the government and society as a whole. They advocate the protection of life,
liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. This
involves not defense, but offense. Not
laid back passive tactics, but active ones.
Arrayed against them, they have the agents of the status quo: academics, teachers, pop culture icons, and
even large portions of a bloated federal government and an artificially
secularized court system.
No one ever won a war, cultural or otherwise, by simply
standing still. It is time that
“conservatives” realized this.